The Granary Supper Club in Sherwood, WI serves the best old fashioneds
Old Fashioneds

The Classic Wisconsin Cocktail

Try Our Famous Old Fashioned

Bar Menu
Get Directions
As featured on
Read The Article

Classic Wisconsin Supper Club Dining in Sherwood, WI Welcome to The Granary Supper Club

For over 60 years, The Granary Supper Club has been a Sherwood dining favorite. From our Saturday night prime rib and Friday fish fry to our handcrafted old fashioneds, we serve timeless favorites with warm hospitality. Enjoy a full soup and salad bar with every meal and experience true Wisconsin supper club tradition.

View All Menus
Order Online
Two plates of steak topped with sautéed mushrooms, served with baked potatoes, sour cream, cheese, and asparagus are beautifully arranged on metal trays at The Granary Supper Club. A knife rests on the side for a classic dining experience.

Explore What’s Cooking at The Granary Supper Club Discover Your Supper Club Favorites

Satisfy Your Cravings Steaks, Seafood, Sandwiches & More

Main Menu

Full Bar & Classic Cocktails Tap Beers, Wines & Old Fashioneds

Bar Menu

What’s Cooking Today? Check Out Our Daily Specials

Daily Specials

Follow, Like & Share with Us on Facebook Stay Connected with The Granary

Rated One of the Best Supper Clubs in Sherwood, WI Our Guests Say It Best

From the tender prime rib to our warm, welcoming atmosphere, guests love what we’re serving at The Granary. Read our 5-star reviews and see why we’re a local favorite for dinner, drinks, and special occasions.

the-granary-supper-club-sherwood-wisconsin-restaurant-bar-5-star-reviews

“Came here on a Friday night during dinner rush and yet was able to be seated within 20 minutes. Soup and salad bar had lots of options to choose from and their tenderloin tips were prepared down to perfection (med-rare). Great staff that make amazing old fashions.”

Ashley | Google Review

the-granary-supper-club-sherwood-wisconsin-restaurant-bar-5-star-reviews

“Service was dead on. The salad bar was plentiful and fresh. The entrées were way more than enough food for us. Quality of food was very good to excellent.”

Stephen | Google Review

the-granary-supper-club-sherwood-wisconsin-restaurant-bar-5-star-reviews

“Hands down one of the best supper clubs I’ve been to! From the minute we walked in, the service was amazing. My 8oz tenderloin was cooked perfect, the salad bar... top notch... and the homemade potato puff was nothing but perfection!”

Monica | Google Review

A cooked brisket glazed with barbecue sauce is served on an oval metal platter with a handle, set inside a black serving tray at The Granary Supper Club—perfect for anyone searching for the Best Food in town. A knife is partially visible under the brisket.

Private Dining Rooms Available for Groups Up to 150+ Host Your Next Event With Us

Whether you're planning a birthday, anniversary, business dinner, or holiday gathering, The Granary Supper Club offers three spacious dining rooms and custom menu options to make your event special. Contact us today to learn more about hosting your private party in Sherwood, WI.

Private Parties
Two plates of grilled meat, one with a large steak and a side of broccoli, the other with glazed ribs, served at Sherwood Restaurant. Three small cups of creamy white dipping sauce sit nearby, adding to the Best Food experience.
A tall glass filled with an orange iced cocktail, garnished with red cherries and a pink straw, sits on a speckled countertop at Sherwood Bar, inviting guests to unwind in its vibrant bar setting.
Grilled pork chop with char marks, served with a knife, golden brown diced potatoes, and a piece of corn on the cob on a white plate—a classic at The Granary Supper Club, known for the Best Food in town.
A creamy milkshake topped with whipped cream and a cherry, served in a curved glass with a straw at Sherwood Restaurant, placed on a white napkin on the countertop.
A vibrant salad bar at Sherwood Restaurant features trays of leafy greens, shredded carrots, and cabbage in the front, with bowls of the Best Food toppings like tomatoes, broccoli, olives, mushrooms, peas, and shredded cheese in the background.
A plate of cooked shrimp on a bed of green leaf lettuce, sprinkled with seasoning, served with a lemon wedge, cocktail sauce, and a side of tartar sauce at The Granary Supper Club. Fried food is visible in the background.
A close-up of a grilled sandwich halved on a white plate at Sherwood Restaurant, filled with tomato, cheese, and vegetables. A pickle spear and a small container of dipping sauce are visible in the background—enjoy the best food around!.
Enjoy the Best Food at Sherwood Bar—a steak sandwich with tomatoes, lettuce, a pickle spear, a biscuit, and white dipping sauce on the side. A knife rests atop the bun for easy sharing.